By Emily Stahl
Trojan Tribune Staff
Photo Courtesy of Visual Photos
For me, ‘books to movies’ always sounds like a good idea. However, they are sometimes a disappointment. I went to see the newest book to movie filmed, The Hunger Games, and thought it definitely lacked important details. It brings to mind how books translate to movies and how it’s sometimes a wonderful, or terrible, idea. Some well-known books to movies include The Hunger Games, the Twilight series, and the Harry Potter series. Sometimes books to movies work out really well, and other times it just gets lost in the translation.
The Hunger Games book was amazing. It was descriptive and it allowed the readers to get to
know the characters “personally”. The two main characters’ (Peeta and Katniss) relationship was prominent in the book and was the main focus. However, in the movie, Peeta doesn’t appear to be in love with Katniss, and we didn’t get to know the other characters very well. I was also disappointed with the small amount of action they had in the film. In my opinion, they ruined their chances for the next movie as well.
The Harry Potter book series did not disappoint. For those who can get past the fact that it’s about wizards and witches, it’s a great story for guys and girls to read. The books show the troubles and triumphs of growing up, and the books have a lot of action. The movies were also well put together. They had action, portrayed the relationships in detail, and had an amazing cast. In my opinion, all the characters were spot on. There were some times when I was a little disappointed with how they did a scene, or excluded something, but for the most part I was impressed.
The Twilight series wasn’t a terrible read, but it was a little sappy. The main character, Bella, really infuriated me at times. She kept going back and forth between her two “loves” and came off as needy. Nevertheless, if you like stories about true love with a little twist, I would suggest this series. The use of mythical creatures, as cheesy as that sounds, didn’t come off as strange; we just got used to them that way. The movies weren’t terrible, but they weren’t amazing, either. The acting could’ve been way better; some of the cast just wasn’t made for acting. I have mixed feelings about the movies, but I definitely liked the books better.
All in all, books to movies is a hit and miss process. Everyone is going to have a different opinion on them. Someone may love the books but not the movies; others may love the movies but not the books, or they might love both! It’s really up to the reader and the viewer’s opinion whether it’s a disaster or a great production.






